Collaborative sex stories let us write the plot together

(Her Secret Fantasy, continued by JustAName...)

Hearing no objections, you all prepare for the next round. When everyone is ready, you give the countdown and the action begins!

You immediately begin dodging the attacks from Zoey, who started to go after you. While swimming away from her, you also quickly dodge the maneuvers from your girlfriend. Riley seems to have busied herself with Jamie, so you take this opportunity to pull her bra strings off as you pass by. Her bra floats off in the water before she realizes it, and she continues her chase after Jamie.

The action seems to have caught Rachel’s eye, and she stops to watch it. As she is doing so, you successfully tug her bra off as well. However, in your stride you have also gotten yourself tagged. Zoey was chasing you the whole time, and finally caught up as you slowed to take care of Rachel. She yanks your shorts down, exposing your half-stiff cock. You immediately chase her after you kick your shorts free in the water and begin a mad chase.

Meanwhile, Jamie is still managing to stay away from Riley, who is now receiving help from Rachel. As he begins to run out of options, you successfully catch up to Zoey and grab onto her arm. This is the moment you proposed for, and the shocked look on her face tells you that you made the right choice. Everyone halts as you tell Zoey what to do.

“We will go over on the stairs to do this,” you tell her. “Let me get fully hard first.”

You jerk your cock a few times while swimming over to the stairs, where Zoey has already made herself comfortable (as comfy as you can get on pool stairs). You begin to mount her missionary style in the water, rubbing your cock against her pussy lips. She nods, signaling you to proceed. Jamie, Rachel and Riley watch you with anxiousness as you slowly slide your cock into Zoey underwater.

Her snug and tight pussy feels amazing, especially in the warm water, as you begin to pick up your thrusting pace which the water limits. You pump into her constantly for the next few minutes while she moans.

You are nearing your edge when you push Zoey over hers, and she climaxes right on your cock. You almost burst yourself, but manage to hold yourself together. You keep yourself balls deep in her until her orgasm is over. Once she’s done, you slowly slide out of her, showing your concrete-hard cock to everyone else.

“Good job,” you tell her. “You’re still in the game. Let’s all prepare and start round two!” you exclaim, while your hard cock is jutting out in front of you, pulsing. That’s how close you were. You’re very frustrated that you didn’t get to cum in her yet. You quickly begin the countdown and start the next round.