Collaborative sex stories let us write the plot together

(Her Secret Fantasy, continued by Anon...)

Hesitantly you read the message.

“Seems I found a smart watch! Hit me up if ya want it back for the owner. Lucky they had the ICE contact set up! I’ll send though my from my phone.”

A second text follows with a phone number. Hoping it’s just some rando who found Rachel’s watch you message back.

“That’s great, gimme your address and I’ll stop by.”

Waiting for the reply you still can’t stop worrying that it’s Jimmy. Although that might give you the opportunity to test the waters and see if your plan to keep him out of the picture worked. Or it could go horribly wrong. Suddenly you realize that Rachel will also be receiving any messages to and from her smart watch as she still has her phone and they obviously share the number. Quickly you head things off with a text.

“Don’t worry babe I got this. Sorting out picking your watch up now”

Rachel, or at least you think it’s Rachel, replies, “Thanks hon! See you after work!”

A few seconds later, a message comes in on your phone from the unknown caller. “I assume you’re the boyfriend. Yeah?”

Trying to keep it short, you reply in the affirmative, and ask for the address again. The response makes your heart sink.

“Coolio! I know where you live, so I’ll stop by in five and return Rachel’s watch. We can have a nice chat in private”

It’s obviously Jimmy. Of course he knows where you live — he picked up your naked zombie girlfriend taking out the trash. He certainly remembers Rachel’s name too. This doesn’t bode well and you hadn’t banked in this eventuality.

What are you going to do when he arrives?