Collaborative sex stories let us write the plot together

(Her Secret Fantasy, continued by k.kikkiriccio...)

While Monica’s back is to you, Rachel gets your attention. She points vigorously at her friend, mouthing silently to you, “grab her,” and then makes squeezing motions with her hands.

You go up behind Monica and press against her, hands on her shoulders. “Oooh,” she says, and wiggles her butt back against you. Rachel gives you a thumbs-up as you place your hands on Monica’s buttcheeks and run them up her back. Then your hands glide around to the front and cup her breasts. She turns around and purrs, “Oooh, look who’s all naughty?”

“Couldn’t help myself,” you reply. “Sorry, not sorry.” You all have a laugh.

While the water heats, you sit at the kitchen table with your juice, and Monica takes a long sip of hers while looking at you, and then licks the glass. She hugs against you as you kiss her stomach, and swear she’s trying to rub her tits on your face. Rachel is standing with her own glass watching you, and you ask her “You’re okay with this?”

“Of course. I don’t invite my friend over to bop around the house dressed in skimpy lingerie every day, do I?” Then she adds, “I want you to do her.”

“Hmmm,” you say, caressing her friend. “What do you mean by ‘do’?”

“Whatever you decide.”

Monica sets her glass down and straddles you, lowering her crotch to yours, which is already a half-boner straining against your briefs.

“You’re not jealous?” you ask Rachel. “You don’t want to join?”

“I want to watch you. I’ve always wanted to watch, and here we are.” She smiles as your attention turns to Monica’s tits which are now right in front of your face. “Besides, I already… well, got some… satisfaction, if you know what I mean.”

“Oh yeah?” you squeeze Monica’s butt with one hand and a breast with the other.

“Um, yeah. Tell me you saw the… well, the ‘evidence’ up there?”

“Oh, yeah, I saw. Funny, I didn’t even know you owned a dildo.”

“I don’t.” You look at them both. “That’s right, it’s hers. We share.” Then she laughs, realizing the humour of the situation.

You have to make yourself not feel bad for turning your attention away from your girlfriend, but you definitely want to make Monica feel like she’s turning you on (she is!), and you know Rachel wants you to have her. You assume you’ll have sex with her, with your girlfriend watching — what else, given the set up? You totally want to, and you know Monica wants it, and you know Rachel wants you to, but you still feel weird about it.