Collaborative sex stories let us write the plot together

(Her Secret Fantasy, continued by Anon...)

John looks back at you, and seems to be thinking hard about Rachel’s suggestion before continuing. “Gimme a second, I’ll be right back!” he mutters before getting up and walking briskly away.

Making sure John is well out of earshot, Rachel leans towards you and hurriedly whispers, “Well, it looks like you’re going to get that ring-side seat after all! This could be sooo much fun… but you’ll have to play along. Remember you’re not my boyfriend, so don’t act like it. You’re just a random dude who’s up for a three-way with some slut. So just go with it and have a good time. Got it?”

Rachel’s bluntness takes you back a bit, but she has a point. If you start acting all protective then John might get suspicious. That would be bad. Anyway, it’s not every day your girlfriend tells you to enjoy banging her with another guy. You can’t believe how lucky you can be, and marvel at how cleverly Rachel turned things around and got you back in the action! “Okay, got it. You’re a slut, and I’m just a dude who’s gunna spit-roast you with your boss. Check.”

“Spit-roast me? Hmmm, that does sound like fun! But I want John’s big cock in my pussy, so you’re going to have to make do with my mouth. Well, the first time at least!” laughs Rachel.

“Make do? That pretty mouth looked very talented just now. I’m sure I’ll enjoy myself!” you laugh in return.

“Settle down! Here comes John!” shushes Rachel. You look over and sure enough, John is hurrying back.

“That was a fine suggestion Rachel, and Ross, thanks for giving her the idea!” says John, smiling.

“Not a problem, always happy to help! Are you parked outside? If not, we can all take my car?” you reply, starting to get up. John stops you with a firm hand on your shoulder.

“Sorry Ross, but neither of us really know you. I don’t feel comfortable with a random stranger I just met”, states John matter-of-factly. It’s a fair principle, you can see that, but this is starting to sound troubling. John has clearly just found someone else.

“But John, I like Ross! He’s cute!” interjects your girlfriend quickly looking at you with more than a little concern, “I’m not sure about this. I don’t want to get a reputation with your friends either!” she goes on trying to turn things around again. So considerate and quick thinking. She’s a keeper for sure, you think.

“That may be, Rachel”, responds John, “But who knows? He could be a nutter and want to fuck me instead of you! No, I think it best if we hook up with someone I know,” explains John. “Don’t worry about your reputation. We’ll all keep it a secret” he winks, turning to you. “Ross, don’t feel bad. I appreciate that you haven’t had a piece of Rachel, and that must be a real disappointment. You’ve probably got a case of blue balls after seeing her boobs and then suck my cock. But it’s not like you don’t have something to remember her by right?” he winks. “But tell you what, I’m here every Saturday night. If we get to know each other over the next few weeks, I’ll let you in on the action.”