Collaborative sex stories let us write the plot together

(Her Secret Fantasy, continued by Anon...)

“I need to go clean up, I’m such a mess!” Rachel blurts out as she starts to get off the bed, but she is stopped in her tracks by Paul.

“No way! You look so hot with your face covered in cum Rachel!” As he walks toward your girlfriend he continues, “Just like a slutty glazed doughnut!”

Rachel stifles a giggle and sits back down on the edge of the bed, seemingly relaxed by Paul’s comment. Looking at her you have to admit that Paul does have a point. The smeared lipstick and shiny cum around her mouth do look like strawberry frosting. Strawberry has never been your favorite, but your dick tells you that might change.

“Wow! That’s ummm… a compliment I suppose?” replies Rachel, still giggling.

“If you say so,” shrugs Paul as he whips out his cock. Rachel’s eyes widen as she takes in its length. Then she smiles. “Hmmm… certainly long enough, but it’s a bit on the thin side after Dan!”

Dan and John laugh, and Paul eventually joins in. “I’ll take that as a compliment as well. But I’m not letting you off that easy. I bet you can’t make it half-way. In fact you’re gunna leave a lipstick mark as proof!”

“Really? After John and Dan, I think I have it covered. Gimme a sec, I’ll have to fix my lippy!” Rachel retorts, skipping off camera presumably to the bathroom.

You can hear the guys laughing, as the camera turns and John’s face fills the screen. “Ross! I reckon your little girlfriend has either lost her mind or completely forgot that you’re there… either way, thanks mate!” he whispers. “Oh, here she is. Gotta go!” and the camera spins back to show Rachel sitting on the bed again.

Paul walks over to your girlfriend. “You said Ross was fove and half inches? That’s about here, yeah?” he says, holding his cock about two thirds of the way.

“Hmmm… a little less I think… hmmm… about here,” responds Rachel, as though pointing out the length of her boyfriend’s dick on another man’s cock was the most natural thing in the world to do.

“Okay, open wide,” says Paul. Rachel just lifts his cock and slides her lips down until they touch her fingers. “Nice! Let’s mark that shall we? You’re gunna really need to rub those lips about a bit though!” he continues with a chuckle.

You groan as you see Rachel move her lips back and forth the way you’ve seen her do many times before to smooth out freshly applied lipstick. Your dick throbs at the sight of the bright red ring glistening with saliva come into view as Rachel carefully removes her wide open mouth from Paul’s cock, careful not to smudge her handiwork.

Rachel leans over and picks up the lipstick off the bed and goes about reapplying it. Smiling up at Paul, she asks, “You were saying? Wanna try again, I didn’t even gag?”

“Gag on this!” exclaims Paul, feigning being hurt, as he takes your girlfriend’s chin in his hand and thrusts his cock at her lips. Rachel opens her mouth in response and you see Paul’s cock disappear inside it.

As the red lipstick ring marking your length disappears past your girlfriend’s lips you reach down and take your own dick out and start stroking off, moving your hand in time with the red ring appearing from within Rachel’s lips. As it goes on you realize with frustration that each stroke is slower and slower: Paul is going deeper and deeper, so it takes longer for the lipstick mark to appear with each stroke. Eventually it stops, and Paul pushes a final time. Rachel gags for a second, then relaxes and buries her face into Paul’s pubic hair. Paul’s ass clenches, and he holds Rachel there while her throat moves up and down as your girlfriend swallows it all.

Eventually she stops, but Paul holds her still. “Mark it off Rachel, there’s a good little slut!”

Rachel looks up at him, and slowly does that thing again and you can see the lipstick smear around Paul’s cock before she releases it and leans back.

“Wow John, you were right! She’s the best cocksucker ever! Oh man, look at it! Right to the bottom of the jar!” Paul exclaims as he collapses onto the bed.