Collaborative sex stories let us write the plot together

(Her Secret Fantasy, continued by Angelo...)

Rachel cries out again, and you can tell she is about to give in.

“Wait, stop,” you cry out, looking to spare your girlfriend the humiliation. Monica ignores you, intent on her prey.

You step onto the mat and pull her off Rachel. Monica resists you for bit but, once free, she steps away from the mat and Rachel. She has a sour look on her face at having her fun spoiled.

“You okay?” you ask Rachel. She nods, but her tears tell another story.

“What the hell was that?” you ask Monica.

Monica views you both with contempt as she gathers up her clothes. “I thought she wanted a fight. And I thought you wanted to fuck a real woman. Turns out you’re both a disappointment.”

With that, she leaves.

With her gone, you look to comfort Rachel. “I’m… s-sorry, Ross,” she sobs. “I thought I was stronger, but I’m n-not.”

You leave the mat behind and make her a drink. She calms down but doesn’t want to talk about it. You interrupted to spare her, but you both know what happened. As does Monica.

Rachel never mentions wrestling other girls again. And things almost go back to normal, but for the awkward night neither of you talks about — yet which casts a shadow over your relationship.

As for Monica, she and Rachel stop hanging out. Which means you don’t see her at all.

In the end, you are left wondering where it went wrong? Was it a mistake to entertain this fantasy? Or was it a mistake to try and stop it too soon?

You’ll probably never know, but you and Rachel still have one another — and that counts for something.

The End

• Start again